custom cakes: made to order

Wedding Cakes, Birthday Cakes, Graduation Cakes, and More...
Endless Options for Any of Life's Special Occasions

Browse some of our cake selections on this page or visit us on Facebook and Instagram for more pictures and inspiration. If you find one of our cakes with a design that is exactly what you want, please specify this and where you saw it when you place the order.

We are happy to customize any item or flavor to fit your special occasion, dietary needs, and taste buds!

More Options on Facebook!

CONTACT US FOR A CONSULT

Cake Care Instructions & Tips

There are a lot of bakeries in Green Bay and the surrounding communities, so we are very honored and appreciative that you entrusted Naturally Delightful with the responsibility of providing your celebration with the cake.

Whether for a birthday, wedding, anniversary, graduation, or some other special occasion, the cake always serves as an essential centerpiece. For this reason, we want its flavor and freshness protected once it leaves our hands and is placed into yours.

To help you with this, please see the adjoining cake care instructions and tips. And if you ever have any follow-up questions or concerns, feel free to give our bakery a call or send us a message.

Thank you, and Enjoy!

some Classic flavors & favorites

Please Note: Listed prices are reflected of our STANDARD DOUBLE LAYER ROUND CAKE. This height is customizable upon request.

If you would like help determining the cake height or size that is right for your occasion, you can use our Cake Cutting Guide pictured above, or just ask us when you place your order. We'd love to help!

chocolate & Vanilla

Vanilla on Vanilla
Chocolate on Chocolate
Vanilla on Chocolate
Chocolate on Vanilla​

• 6" Double Round - $38 
• 8" Double Round - $50
• 10" Double Round - $68
• 12" Double Round - $88
• 14" Double Round - $106
• 16" Double Round - $130

carrot cake

Top it with the traditional cream cheese or brown sugar frosting​

• 6" Double Round - $40 
• 8" Double Round - $50
• 10" Double Round - $69
• 12" Double Round - $90
• 14" Double Round - $110
• 16" Double Round - $132

CHOCOLATE CAKE WITH COOKIE DOUGH FILLING AND FUDGe

• 6" Double Round - $42 
• 8" Double Round - $56
• 10" Double Round - $72
• 12" Double Round - $92 
• 14" Double Round - $113
• 16" Double Round - $137
• Additional Cookies on Top of the Cake = Starting at $9.00

Vanilla cake with strawberries & cream

• 6" Double Round - $42 
• 8" Double Round - $55
• 10" Double Round - $73
• 12" Double Round - $94 
• 14" Double Round - $115
• 16" Double Round - $140
• Add Fresh Strawberries on Top of the Cake = Starting at $7.00 (depends if the strawberries are in season)

Chocolate Salted Caramel

(Sorry, but we are unable to write on this flavor of cake due to the caramel on the top layer) 

• 6" Double Round - $42
• 8" Double Round - $56
• 10" Double Round - $72
• 12" Double Round - $92 
• 14" Double Round - $113
• 16" Double Round - $137